Newsletter #556 – Keep Calm and Carry On?

Keep Calm and Carry OnThis week I have two close friends who are facing career-defining exams. Both of my friends are approaching this with understandable anxiety. It was appropriate, then, that I forwarded each a copy of “Feeling Anxious? Why Trying to Keep Calm is a Terrible Idea” published in the Fast Company daily blog on December 2, 2013. Each day the blog gives several practical, brief articles relating to leadership and career issues. Anyone can subscribe for free at

The article sent to my friends describes highly visible, boldly-fonted World War II signs that were posted all over Britain. The message, Keep Calm And Carry On encouraged war-ravaged British people to try keeping calm and going about their normal activities even when bombs were dropping almost every night. That’s a terrible idea says the Fast Company writer because staying cool under pressure “totally misses the way emotions work. Anxiety is an automatic physiological arousal in the presence of potential danger. Keeping calm is a cognitive response that rarely works in the presence of physical arousal. “Since arousal is so automatic, it’s hard to control….very, very difficult to do successfully especially leading up to very anxiety-inducing tasks” or experiences.

A better solution is to get excited. This lets the body stay in an amped-up physiological state while the mind goes to something better that focuses away from the fear. In a Harvard study of public speakers nervous about an important speech, subjects who told themselves to get excited performed better: “they gave more persuasive, competent, and persuasive speeches” than those who tried to calm down or others who did nothing to deal with the anxiety.

In reading, I wondered if this is a variation of the power of positive thinking. I wondered, too, if this would have worked with Londoners, told to get excited during the Battle of Britain. Nevertheless, the researcher noted that anxiety distracts us from focusing on real solutions and functioning effectively. Other emotions let us focus on what needs to be done to get past the anxious situations.

What do you think? Please comment.



  1. Anxiety is a normal response to important events in our life. Diminishing the importance to calm anxiety doesn’t feel right. Learning to live with the anxiety and use it to give me energy in the event is the appropriate response it seems. Knowing God is for me and guides my steps keeps the energy from moving to panic.


  2. Anxiety as a physiological response to either perceived or real danger is a God-given way to deal with the danger. When it morphs into being anxious it becomes a problem.


  3. ‘Keep calm and carry on’ was aimed at a specific situation, and it’s not comparable to the situation most people face in day to day life (unless they live in a war zone). The Blitz went on for nearly nine months. Being anxious in that situation was natural, but calling it ‘excitement’ would have been equally useless – both anxiety and excitement gear the body and brain up for action, but what action? There was nothing the average Glaswegian or Londoner could have done to change the situation, and they couldn’t just stop living until it was over. In that, fortunately unusual situation, keep calm and carry on was probably the best option.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s